What is happening inside the tank?
The sound you hear is the fill valve, the part that refills the tank after a flush. It is easy to blame it, and Korky notes that because you can hear the fill valve working, people assume it is the main problem. Fluidmaster describes ghost flushing differently: it is the fill valve's way of letting you know water is leaking out of the tank.
In other words, the refill is a symptom. Water is slipping out of the tank a little at a time, the level falls, and the fill valve opens for a few seconds to replace it. Then the cycle starts again, sometimes every few minutes and sometimes only a few times a night.
The Arizona Municipal Water Users Association (AMWUA) says toilet leaks are mostly silent and that toilets are the most likely fixtures to be wasting water inside a home. A refill you can hear is one of the few times a toilet leak announces itself.
What usually causes it?
Most of the time the leak is at the bottom of the tank. Korky says that in most cases a worn flapper or flush valve seal is letting water slowly leak from the tank into the bowl, and Fluidmaster calls flapper leaks the most common leak point. The City of Mesa says about 20 percent of toilets leak and that the rubber flapper is often the culprit.
These are the causes the manufacturers and Valley water agencies name:
- A worn or warped flapper. AMWUA's Smart Home Water Guide suggests replacing a flapper every 3 to 5 years because they are prone to warping and leaking, and Fluidmaster says to simply change one that is more than 5 years old.
- Debris or mineral deposits on the seat. Fluidmaster says to check the rubber surface of a newer flapper for debris, and Korky says to clean mineral deposits off the drain opening so the flapper can seal.
- A chain that is too long, too short or caught. Korky recommends only 1 to 2 links of slack, and Fluidmaster says to cut excess chain that interferes with the flapper seating.
- A water level set too high. The Smart Home Water Guide says the water should sit a half-inch below the top of the overflow tube. Higher than that, water spills down the tube and the fill valve keeps replacing it.
- A refill tube pushed down into the overflow pipe. Fluidmaster says to reposition it so it does not enter the pipe.
- A fill valve that does not shut off. Korky says water that keeps running after the tank is full is a sign the float may be stuck or malfunctioning.
How do I do the food coloring test?
The dye test takes a few minutes and needs nothing but food coloring. Valley cities describe it almost the same way:
- Take the lid off the tank and add a few drops of food coloring to the tank water. The City of Chandler says 2 or 3 drops.
- Do not flush or use the toilet. The EPA's WaterSense program says to check after 10 minutes; the Smart Home Water Guide and the City of Glendale say to wait 15 minutes, and Chandler says 15 to 30.
- Look in the bowl. If color shows up there, water is leaking from the tank. Chandler and Glendale both say that result means the flapper needs to be replaced.
- Flush a couple of times afterward so the coloring does not sit in the tank or bowl.
How do I tell whether it is the flapper or something else?
The dye test proves there is a leak, but Fluidmaster points out that it does not show where the leak is. Its water-level test narrows that down. With the tank full, turn the water off at the shut-off valve behind the toilet and do not flush. Mark the water level inside the tank with a pencil, then wait 30 minutes. Korky describes the same pencil-mark check: if the level drops below the mark, a part in the tank is leaking.
Where the water stops tells you more. Fluidmaster says water that drains down to the lip of the flapper points to the flapper or the seat it rests on, while water that drains to the bottom of the tank points to the gasket under the flush valve, a bigger repair that involves taking the tank off the bowl.
If the level does not drop at all with the water off, the leak is on the supply side: look at the water level against the overflow tube and at the fill valve.
How much water does it waste, and will my meter show it?
More than most people expect. The City of Glendale says a faulty flapper can waste up to 600 gallons per month. The City of Phoenix puts it simply: a running toilet is a leaky toilet.
Your water meter can confirm a leak, with one caution. The Smart Home Water Guide says a low-flow indicator that moves while no water is being used means a continuous leak, but it also warns that some leaks are very slow and may not show as continuous flow. A toilet that refills only now and then fits that description, so the EPA's longer check is the better one: read the meter before and after a two-hour period when no water is used.
One habit shortens a flapper's life. The Smart Home Water Guide says chlorine products in the tank may decrease the life of the flapper, and Fluidmaster tells owners not to use in-tank drop-in bowl cleaners that contain bleach or chlorine.
When is it time to call a plumber?
Replacing a flapper is a common do-it-yourself repair. Take the old one to the store so the new one matches, because flappers are not all the same size. It makes sense to call a plumber when a new flapper does not stop the refilling, when the water-level test points to the flush valve gasket, when the shut-off valve behind the toilet will not turn or drips, or when the toilet is old enough that parts are hard to match.
Age matters for water use, too. The City of Scottsdale notes that homes built before 1980 have toilets that use 5 to 7 gallons per flush, and the EPA's WaterSense label goes to toilets that use 1.28 gallons per flush or less. If an old toilet needs more than a flapper, replacing it may be worth pricing alongside the repair.
Common questions
Is a toilet that refills by itself an emergency?
No. The water is going down the drain, not onto the floor, so it will not damage the house. It does waste water every hour until it is fixed, so plan the repair soon rather than living with it.
How often should a toilet be checked for leaks?
The City of Scottsdale recommends checking for toilet leaks once a year with the food coloring test. The EPA says the flapper should be checked periodically and replaced at least every five years.
The dye test showed nothing, but the toilet still refills. What now?
Run the test again and wait the full 30 minutes Chandler allows, since a slow leak takes time to show. Then check that the water level sits a half-inch below the top of the overflow tube and that the refill tube is not pushed down inside it.
Can I use bleach tablets in the tank to keep the bowl clean?
It is better not to. Fluidmaster warns against in-tank drop-in cleaners that contain bleach or chlorine and says using them voids the warranty on its parts. AMWUA's Smart Home Water Guide says chlorine products may shorten the life of the flapper.
Sources
- EPA WaterSense: Fix a Leak Week
- EPA WaterSense: Residential Toilets
- AMWUA Smart Home Water Guide: Indoor Visual Leak Inspection
- AMWUA Smart Home Water Guide: How to Read Your Water Meter
- AMWUA: Fix a Leak Week, Save Water and Money
- City of Phoenix: Water Conservation
- City of Mesa: Your Water. Your Impact.
- City of Chandler: How to Check for a Water Leak
- City of Glendale: Fix Leaks One at a Time
- City of Scottsdale: HOA and Multifamily Residences (water conservation)
- Fluidmaster: Leaking Toilet Flapper
- Fluidmaster: Water Leaking from Tank to Bowl
- Korky: How to Stop Ghost Flushing
- Korky: How to Fix a Running Toilet
